UCHastings Instagram

@hastingswlj EIC Sonya L. Rahders kicks off the "Bringing to Light" Symposium. #UCHastings
Instagram Photo Likes ms_lagunitas, dan1sha, kmatayoshi and 20 others like this.
Thursday, August 01, 2013

Adjunct Joseph Gratz: Does Resale Market for Online Music Violate Copyright Act?

ReDigi says its service is protected by the Copyright Act’s first-sale principle, which would allow people to resell their used CDs at flea markets or online. The doctrine, originally set out by the U.S. Supreme Court in 1908, provides that copyright owners can’t prevent people who have purchased material from reselling it.

But the record industry views the service differently. The major labels contend that ReDigi makes unauthorized copies of MP3s. The industry says that even if first-sale principles let people resell what they have purchased, they can’t sell a copy of that material—regardless of whether it is a homemade recording of an album or an MP3 file.

Despite technology companies’ interest in enabling sales of used digital media, some copyright experts say ReDigi will have an uphill battle. “The standard view is that whenever you’re making a new copy, you’re infringing the reproduction right,” says Joseph Gratz, an adjunct faculty member at the University of California’s Hastings College of the Law in San Francisco. “Making new copies is something that you’re not allowed to do without a license.”

At the same time, Gratz adds, the rationale behind the prohibition on copying is to enable the owner to control the total number of copies in the world. If a system like ReDigi’s deletes the user’s version as it uploads a copy to the company’s servers, the total number of copies in existence remains constant. That’s different from file-sharing services, where countless people can download the same track after one consumer has uploaded it.

Read the full story in the ABA Journal here.

Go to News Archive

Share this Story

Share via Facebook
Share via TwitterShare via EmailPrint Friendly Version

Other Recent Stories/ RSS

Friday, January 23, 2015

Thinkers & Doers: January 23, 2015

UC Hastings community members in the news and making moves January 17, 2014 - January 23, 2015.
Thursday, January 22, 2015

2L Trailblazer Liliana Garcia

"We might have had less growing up,” she said, “but I actually had more support emotionally, and that is what people need to get through anything.”
Wednesday, January 21, 2015

New Study Reveals "Double Jeopardy" Faced by Women of Color in STEM

Professor Joan C. Williams and the Center for WorkLife Law released the report, which demonstrates in startling fashion how subtle—and not-so-subtle—bias shapes the daily work lives of women in STEM, and how women’s experience of gender bias is shaped by race.
Tuesday, January 20, 2015

New AALS Section on East Asian Law and Society Points to Region’s Growing Prominence

Professor Miyazawa was elected as the first Chair.
Tuesday, January 20, 2015

Mark Werbner Lectures on Anti-Terrorism Litigation

His 10-year-long case held a financial institution civilly liable for providing services to Hamas.
Go to News Archive