Wednesday, October 30, 2013

          Professor Ben Depoorter and Robert Kirk Walker '13 Examine "False Positives" in Copyright Enforcement

          Professor Depoorter collaborated with a former student on the new article, forthcoming from Notre Dame Law Review.
          Ben Depoorter

          Ben Depoorter

          UC Hastings Professor Ben Depoorter and Robert Walker ‘13 examine the implications and dangers of enforcement “false positives” in the area of copyright.

          Applying new technologies, copyright holders increasingly sweep the net to detect alleged infringements and issue takedown notices. As the authors demonstrate, these largely automated enforcement processes fail to take into account the fine contours of copyright law and the rights reserved to the public (fair use, etc.).

          Overbroad copyright enforcement chills freedom of expression, inflates litigation costs, and bogs down a system already mired with complexities and challenges. The article, forthcoming in Notre Dame Law Review Volume 89 in 2014, explains the trend of copyright enforcement false positives and offers policy recommendations and solutions.

          From the Abstract

          Copyright enforcement is riddled with false positives. A false positive occurs when enforcement actions are taken against uses that are not actual infringements. Far from benign occurrences, copyright false positives inflict significant social harm in the form of increased litigation and transaction costs, distortions of licensing markets through rent-seeking behavior, increased piracy due to diminished public adherence with copyright law, and the systemic erosion of free speech rights and the public domain.

          To combat this problem, this Article analyzes the causes that give rise to false positives, as well as their legal and social effects, and offers policy recommendations targeted at mitigating the damage of false positives. These policy recommendations include heightening the registration requirements to include a substantive review of all copyright claims; the promulgation of regulations dictating that copyright registrations be periodically renewed; and revision to the statutory damage provisions of the Copyright Act in order to encourage litigation that would help to excise false positives from the copyright corpus.

          About the Authors

          Professor Ben Depoorter is a graduate of Yale Law School (L.L.M., J.S.D.). He also holds a JD (1999) and PhD (2003) from Ghent University and a Master's degree from the University of Hamburg (2001). Depoorter received the Roger Traynor scholarship prize at UC Hastings in 2011. He currently holds the Roger J. Traynor Research Chair at UC Hastings and is an Affiliate Scholar at the Stanford University Center for Internet & Society. Professor Depoorter's scholarly interests include the enforcement of copyright law, property law theory, technology and intellectual property law, with an emphasis on behavioral research.

          Robert Kirk Walker is an Affiliate Scholar and Research Fellow with the Technology and Privacy Project at UC Hastings College of the Law.

          ##

          Go to News Archive

          Share this Story

          Share via Facebook
          Share via TwitterShare via EmailPrint Friendly Version

          Other Recent Stories/ RSS

          Thursday, July 12, 2018

          A Q&A with Andrew Scott, UC Hastings College of the Law’s New Director of Human Resources

          "It's about everyone, as part of the team, being excited about the end goal and understanding that they play a big part in it."
          Friday, July 06, 2018

          Joe Veith '08 Defends Parents Separated from Children at Border

          He is on the front line of the family separation crisis in El Paso, Texas.
          Tuesday, July 03, 2018

          Thinkers & Doers: June 2018

          Inside the battle to save California’s water – Addressing rampant pregnancy discrimination at companies – Say Yes to Pro Bono – Enough with the racist gestures at the World Cup – Alum invests in properties to house the homeless in LA – Back to the Dark Ages of Rights for Women? – Hastings Law Journal article cited by Supreme Court – and much more
          Monday, June 25, 2018

          California Invests $4.5 Million in UC Hastings Diversity Pipeline Collaboration

          Initial offering of the “California Scholarship” at UC Hastings covers tuition, majority of living costs in San Francisco for students from HBCUs, AUA.
          Monday, June 25, 2018

          In Defense of Government Designation of Protected Areas

          "Now is not the time to turn away from a strategy that has produced such demonstrable progress," writes Professor John Leshy, former Solicitor of the U.S. Department of the Interior, with Wyss Foundation President Molly McUsic.
          Go to News Archive