Fiat Justitia

          Justice is what you do.

          Why We Work For Justice
          The UC Hastings seal carries the words fiat justitia -- Let Justice Be Done. This motto is not a hollow promise; it is who we are and what we do.

          School Spirit

          Funky Chicken

          After 138 years of teaching law and producing first-class legal scholarship, we began to wonder if perhaps we are just a little too focused. Maybe we should look a little more like other institutions...
          Friday, May 04, 2018

          UC Hastings Professor Veena Dubal’s Work Plays Role in California Supreme Court Ruling

          “The Dynamex Decision” creates a major change in the landscape for California’s gig economy and follows the path of Professor Dubal’s analysis from her scholarly work.
          Sample alt tag.
          Professor Veena Dubal admitted, “They definitely cited to my paper… and the spirit of the paper is certainly imbued throughout the decision.”

          Creating a major change in the landscape for California’s gig economy, the California Supreme Court issued a ruling that made clear that many workers misclassified as “independent contractors” should actually be considered employees, and UC Hastings Professor Veena Dubal’s work played a role.

          In its decision, published April 30, the state high court cited Dubal’s paper Wage Slave or Entrepreneur?: Contesting the Dualism of Legal Worker Identities (2017) 105 Cal.L.Rev. 65, 72.

          Dubal’s paper provided an overview of the multiple standards courts have used to determine which category a worker falls into, and identified one known as the “ABC standard” as the simplest method to distinguish employees from independent contractors. The state high court’s decision followed the path of Dubal’s analysis, and determined that the ABC standard is the most appropriate one to use.

          ABC, Dubal explained, presumptively considers all workers to be employees. It considers three factors for distinguishing an independent contractor: an employer does not dictate how the independent contractor works, an independent contractor’s trade is, by custom, considered independent, much like a carpenter or a plumber, and, most important, an independent contractor’s work is outside of the usual course of the hiring entity’s business.

          That means a plumber repairing a leak in a dress shop’s plumbing, for example, would be considered an independent contractor, but a seamstress making dresses for the same shop could not be.

          ABC is a “simple, fabulous test,” and far more objective that previously used standards, Dubal said.

          The original legal action in the case was brought by delivery truck drivers for Dynamex Operations West, Inc., whose work was clearly central to the company business, Dubal explained. “Dynamex is a delivery company. These are delivery drivers,” she said. “There’s no way they are not employees.”

          “Easily the most significant legal blow to Uber et al yet,” reporter Noam Scheiber said in a tweet linking to his New York Times story, which called the ruling one “with potentially sweeping consequences.”

          The ruling is expected to have an especially huge impact on Uber and Lyft drivers, who may be entitled to back pay for minimum wage and overtime violations, Dubal said. “It’s particularly significant for people bearing vehicle expenses because that’s what puts people under minimum wage,” she explained. But the ruling is also expected to impact workers in a broad swath of businesses, from construction to nail salons.

          To implement the shift, “It’s gonna take a lot of lawsuits,” Dubal said. But now, the barriers is much lower for workers categorized as independent contractors to be designated as employees, and therefore subject to minimum wage and other employee protections, she explained. “The law is so employee-friendly, it’s going to result in a surge of misclassification litigation to force companies to abide by the laws they were flouting.”

          For smaller- and medium-sized businesses, however, the ruling may shift their business model without litigation, Dubal said. “They’re going to want to avoid it and make sure workers are making minimum wage. There’s a strong incentive to comply that wasn’t there before.”

          As for her role in the decision which has been hailed as a victory for workers, Dubal was modest. “Tons of people have been writing about this for a really long time,” she said. But when pressed, Dubal admitted, “They definitely cited to my paper… and the spirit of the paper is certainly imbued throughout the decision.”

          When asked if that was a gratifying feeling, Dubal confessed, “I had a nice couple of days.”

          ####

          Go to News Archive

          Share this Story

          Share via Facebook
          Share via TwitterShare via EmailPrint Friendly Version

          Other Recent Stories/ RSS

          Friday, May 18, 2018

          UC Hastings Students Speak at UN Human Rights Council in Geneva

          Members of the Hastings Human Rights and International Law Organization attended the 37th Session of the United Nations Human Rights Council to meet diplomats, engage in discussions on human rights issues, and deliver advocacy statements during proceedings.
          Wednesday, May 09, 2018

          Joseph W. Cotchett, Champion for Justice and Titan of the Plaintiffs Bar, is UC Hastings Law's 2018 Commencement Speaker

          Litigation Trial Lawyers Hall of Famer and UC Hastings Alumnus, Class of 1964, to keynote the College’s 137th Commencement
          Friday, May 04, 2018

          Blek le Rat, “The Godfather” of Stencil Graffiti, Contributes Installation at UC Hastings

          The innovative street artist is taking to the streets with works throughout San Francisco to promote a rare North American exhibition.
          Friday, May 04, 2018

          UC Hastings Professor Veena Dubal’s Work Plays Role in California Supreme Court Ruling

          “The Dynamex Decision” creates a major change in the landscape for California’s gig economy and follows the path of Professor Dubal’s analysis from her scholarly work.
          Wednesday, May 02, 2018

          Thinkers & Doers: April 2018

          Professor Dubal cited in the California Supreme Court’s Dynamex decision – Professor Aviram discusses “Sanctuary City” litigation outside the Ninth Circuit – Ellen DeGeneres asks Kamala Harris about 2020 presidential aspirations – How Asylum Works and Doesn’t Work – Professor Ball earns national recognition with 2018 Shanara Gilbert Award – Highlights from the Spring Soirée – and much more
          Go to News Archive